11 Best Cottage Cheeses

Cottage cheese is a favorite among many people who choose this mild flavored product as their go-to dairy option. We have compiled a list of some of the best cottage cheese products you should definitely try. We have also included a few tips on the best way to eat cottage cheese. If you are wondering what goes well with cottage cheese, read through our article! Learn what is the best-tasting cottage cheese, and how to include it in your next delicious recipe. Forget about dry lasagna and discover how to prepare the best lasagna recipe with cottage cheese. So, check out our recommendations, and get ready to enjoy the best cottage cheese on the market.

Top Selected Cheese Products

[amazon box="B00B1OWX2M,B01MTU6DCD, B00IGPKM9U, B00F0ZN3CW, B000LRH54G, B075G5J41N,B00BRD6FJE,B077Z95QCM,B00G3EA4CG" template="table"]

11. Amish Greek Cottage Cheese

If you like Greek-style cheeses and yogurts, you will fall in love with this all-natural product from EcomealOrganic. Super creamy and not very salty, the Amish Greek cottage cheese can be served for breakfast, or as a healthy snack throughout the day. The iconic Greek cuisine is one of the best in the world. So why not use this yummy cottage cheese to prepare a traditional tzatziki or Greek salad?

10. Mountain House, Cottage Cheese

The Mountain House Cottage cheese is a low fat, creamy, delicious side dish you can add to your favorite recipe to increase flavor. Healthy and light cottage cheese obtained from skim milk, the Mountain House product takes only minutes to prepare just by adding water. A favorite among shoppers, Mountain House, is one of best cottage cheese brand names you can find, so be sure to try this delicious product!

Mountain House, Cottage Cheese

9. Breakstones Small Curd Cottage Cheese

A great option for anyone who prefers low fat cheese, Breakstone’s Small Curd Cottage Cheese offers you great taste without having to worry about calories. One of the best cottage cheese for weight loss on the market, this product will provide amazing taste, being ideal to include in your daily diet if you want to stay in shape. You can lose weight without having to let go of your favorite dairy product!

BreakStones Small Curd Cottage Cheese

8. Pirate's Booty Aged White Cheddar

A variation of the cottage cheese brought by Pirate’s Booty is the aged white cheddar with puffed corn and rice. This great tasting snack has no artificial colors or ingredients, which make it an ideal option for the entire family. Gluten-free and low fat, the Pirate Booty’s Aged White Cheddar will turn into a great, convenient snack you can enjoy wherever you are. Perfectly baked, this product offers you great taste without having to worry about gaining weight.

Pirate's Booty Aged White Cheddar

7. Nancy’s Low Fat Cottage Cheese

Another low-fat option you should look into if you want to try the best low fat cottage cheese available, Nancy’s product was designed to meet all taste requirements. Made without vegetable or animal rennet and slowly cultured, this product can be easily included on the list of best cottage cheese to buy if you have a gluten free diet. It is also ideal if you follow a Kosher diet, as Nancy’s Low Fat Cottage Cheese is a certified Kosher product. Including probiotic bacteria, it is also one of the best organic cheese products for health-conscious people.

Nancy’s Low Fat Cottage Cheese

6. Organic Valley Cottage Cheese

A great solution for anyone who wants to enjoy the benefits of organic dairy products, the Organic Valley Cottage Cheese will become a great addition to any classical recipe. It comes in a 16 oz container that you can store in the fridge, and use whenever you want to add a special flavor to your dish. This low-fat product can be safely consumed even if you are on a diet, or simply trying to stay in shape and monitor your weight. Recommended as one of the best tasting cottage cheese available, the Organic Valley product is a delicious and satisfying choice. Light, low-fat and made with organic milk from small family farms, this is another healthy option for those looking for the best organic cottage cheese.

Organic Valley Cottage Cheese

5. Breakstone Cottage Cheese 2% fat

Coming from one of the top cottage cheese brands on the market, the Breakstone Cottage Cheese with 2% fat will become your go-to dairy product. The 4 pack snack size makes this cottage cheese great to take at work, and enjoy throughout the day. It will become your favorite choice for a healthy, but delicious snack, and the kids will enjoy it as well! Choose the yummy Breakstone Cottage Cheese and you will discover that a low fat, healthy option has never tasted so great.

You might also like10 Best Mascarpone Cheeses

Breaktone's Lowfat Cottage Cheese 2% Milkfat

4. Borden Fat Free Cottage Cheese

If you want a product that will enhance the taste of your favorite dips or salad dressings, go for the Borden Fat Free Cottage Cheese. It can transform any dish into the best cottage cheese recipes you have ever tried. Serve this pasteurized cow’s milk product for a healthy lifestyle option. The mild flavor and creamy texture make it the ideal choice for the best cottage cheese pancakes. Easy to introduce in your diet, this curd cottage cheese has a mild, pleasant taste. It also offers you a variety of health benefits with a low-calorie content.

Borden Fat Free Cottage Cheese

3. Horizon Organic Cottage Cheese

If you are looking for the best tasting cottage cheese made from organic ingredients, your search is over. Horizon Organic is one of the best organic cottage cheese brands. They have created an organic product that mixes quality, taste, and vitamins. It is an ideal choice for health-conscious people who love the creamy texture of cottage cheese. Enhanced with special ingredients that protect the distinguished flavor, this low-fat product can satisfy even the pickiest cheese lovers. Go ahead and enjoy the Horizon Organic Cottage Cheese which gives you 15% DV of calcium / serving.

Horizon Organic Cottage Cheese

2. Daisy 4% Cottage Cheese

While it is a bit fatter than other options on this list, Daisy's 4% Cottage Cheese is extremely creamy and very rich. This product is also all-natural, with no added ingredients to make it seem creamy, beating out even so-called organic brands. The perfect replacement for ricotta, it will give your lasagna recipe a plus of taste and creaminess. Or enjoy it as is, it won't disappoint you.

Daisy 4% Cottage Cheese

1. Lactaid 1% Milkfat Low Fat Cottage Cheese

As we age, certain processes in our body slow down. And one of the most common is developing an intolerance to dairy products. Tasting this product you will never realize that it is lactose-free. That's how well Lactaid has made its easy to digest, lactose-free cottage cheese. Their wonder ingredient is the lactase enzyme, missing in regular cottage cheese, added to break down lactose. Best of all, the cheese has 12 grams of protein in every pot, to keep you going throughout your day.

Lactaid 1% Milkfat Low Fat Cottage Cheese

Extra Recommendation - Cheese Making Kit

Not happy with any of the cottage cheeses that you've tried so far? Why not making your own cheese at home? It is healthy, fun, and rewarding. Including easy-to-follow instructions, a thermometer, a cheese cloth, citric acid, rennet (vegetable) and salt, this kit is perfect for novice cheese makers. You will only need to buy unpasteurized milk to start making your own creamy cottage cheese, delicious Ricotta cheese or mozzarella. So, treat your family and friends with the freshest and best-tasting cottage cheese made by you!

Cheese making kit


These best cottage cheese brands and products have affordable prices and can easily be incorporated into your recipes for an extra dash of taste and texture. Go for these creamy, delicious products and you will always have a natural source of calcium and vitamins. Don’t forget to include cottage cheese in your favorite dishes, from lasagna to pancakes and dips. You will see the difference! Turn any meal into a mouth-watering surprise by using the best cottage cheese products on the market!

If you're a big lasagna lover, see what best cheese for lasagna you can use to make it the perfect dish.

Recommended Cheeses For You

[amazon box= "B00P35E0NK,B00MCPHNW4,B006RKX3QK" grid="3"]

(Visited 59,267 times, 13 visits today)

16 responses to “11 Best Cottage Cheeses”

  1. Mary Lackey says:

    What grocery store sells borden cottage cheese not albertson,Tom thumb,wall mart,kroger?

  2. marie masters says:

    Why can’t I get large curd cottage cheese in the lower fat? I shop at Kroger in Michigan. Large curd is 4%. Small curd is 2%. The 2% (small curd) is mushy to me; especially when I add fruit. I usually buy Kroger brand; however, the “name brands” do not offer the lower fat version. Kroger doesn’t either.

  3. Kelly Littleton says:

    Cottage cheese always looked gross but one day I had it with some fruit and it was love at first bite (anyone remember that great comedy from the 70’s?). The best cottage cheeses here provide a lot of variety. The Pirate’s Booty Aged White Cheddar sounds good with its mix of corn and rice. I didn’t know there were cottage cheese blends with cheddar.

    • Selena Bates says:

      Hi Kelly,

      Thank you for your feedback! You can always rely on cottage cheese as a super healthy snack, especially if you are on a diet. And yes, Pirate’s Booty Aged White Cheddar is one of my favorites! Have you tried it?

  4. Andy Shanahan says:

    When you look at the 11 best cottage cheeses, you realize there are not only some great variations on cottage cheese, but there are an astonishing variety of dishes you can make with the different cottage cheeses whether it’s snacks, dinners or desserts. If you like cottage cheese, there’s so much to choose from. If you don’t like cottage cheese, you might change your mind after you try one of these brands.

  5. Patricia Sadler says:

    Is the Daisy 2% small curd cottage cheese good?

    • Selena Bates says:

      Hi Patricia,

      Well, it depends on your tastes, I personally find that both Daisy 4% and 2% fat are creamy and delicious. When you try it, let us know what you think! Thank you!

  6. Curt Bartrug says:

    Daisy 4% is the best I have ever had. Love it with crackers or by itself. Just opening it is heaven for the creamy look and taste.

  7. Barbara says:

    Some years ago, Knudsen made small curd Nonfat Cottage Cheese that I loved. I left the US, came back and could not find it. I’ve tried so many other Cottage Cheese Brands, nonfat, 1,2,4% and they are not like Knudsen nonfat Cottage Cheese small curd. Knudsen’s lowfat is not the same as nonfat small curd was.

  8. Rita. Sharma says:

    I was amazed to try feansba very good cottage cheese for a big commercial brand I read one review that gave HIGH marks to Prairie Farms.

  9. Joy says:

    I recently tried the Horizon organic cottage cheese and it is sooo good. I was not a cottage cheese fan before that, but the taste and texture are really yummy. No fruit needed. Glad to see it at the top of the list!

  10. 1 says:

    the best is hoods cucumber&dill so delish the best doesn’t taste like diet food 2me 7 carbs 5.3 oz it might b only on east coast bc hoods is a Boston firm

  11. Doug Papendick says:

    In Texas, the Borden and Horizon products are terrible. Cottage cheese should not be a watery/soupy texture. The other products listed , I have not seen in North Texas.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.