11 Best Breads for Grilled Cheese

It’s a gloomy, rainy day and you’re scouring the fridge for something hearty and delicious to eat. Luckily, you don’t need an elaborate casserole or expensive takeout; if you have a few slices of bread and a little cheese on hand, you’ve got the makings for one of the planet’s most perfect comfort foods. A toasty, tasty grilled cheese sandwich! While cheese is the star of this sandwich, the right bread will take the taste to a whole new level. Read on to find out which of the many breads available make the best bread for grilled cheese masterpieces.

11. New Grains Gluten Egg Dairy Free English Muffins

best new grains gluten egg bread for grilled cheese
Yes, English muffins can actually make the best bread for grilled cheese! Just cut the muffin in two, layer the cheese on the inside, and close the sandwich. Bake for 10-15 minutes, until the cheese is melted.

Use butter or mayonnaise, as you prefer, and get creative with the add ins: mushrooms, onions, avocado, red pepper. Large, filling, and delicious, each muffin is gluten-free, egg-free, dairy-free, soy and peanut-free.

10. Dave’s Killer Bread

Dave's Killer Bread 21 Grains

Boasting 21 whole grains and seeds, and only 60 calories per slice, you might not expect that this healthful bread will actually taste like, well, bread. Yet its devotees — who are so loyal that they actually call themselves “breadheads” — love the unique combination of nutrition and delicious flavor that this organic loaf provides.

If you fancy yourself a health nut, try the Dave’s Killer Bread. Prepare a killer grilled cheese with a schmear of vegan margarine or mayo on the outside, and raw-milk cheddar or a vegan cheese substitute tucked inside.

Find the perfect cheese: 10 Best Cheeses for Grilled Cheese

9. Martin’s Potato Bread

Martin's Potato Bread

If you’ve ever spent any time in Pennsylvania Dutch country or the surrounding areas, you have probably eaten Martin’s Potato Bread (or the family-owned company’s hot dog and hamburger buns). If not, there’s no time like the present to experience this unique regional product. Potato bread doesn’t taste like potatoes but is buttery and pillowy soft.

Needless to say, it’s one of the best bread for grilled cheese, but also for French toasts or bread puddings. Add a thin slice or two of ham for a truly comforting and satisfying sandwich experience. Best of all? Martin’s Potato Bread contains no high-fructose corn syrup, GMOs, trans fats, artificial dyes, or cholesterol.

8. Hostess White Bread

Hostess White Bread

No grilled cheese roundup article would be complete without the classic pairing of good old fashioned white sandwich bread and American cheese, but there are a few ways to go about making this favorite. Many people feel strongly that white bread is the absolute best bread for grilled cheese, and Hostess has been baking it for almost 100 years.

For a perfectly ooey-gooey filling, turn to individually wrapped American cheese slices or Velveeta; to create the crisp, golden brown exterior, you can butter the white bread or try this tip, which short order cooks in diners swear by: use mayonnaise! Either way, cook this sandwich low and slow to end up with the perfect companion to a piping hot mug of tomato soup.

More delicious cheeses: 10 Best Melting Cheeses

7. San Francisco Boudin Bakery Sourdough

San Francisco Boudin Bakery Sourdough

This handcrafted bread might well be the very best bread for grilled cheese. Why? Well, let’s start with the history behind it. The bakery uses a starter dough that has been nurtured for 150 years as the basis for every batch of bread it produces. With the trademark sourdough tang, this bread can stand up to some flavorful cheeses.

How about a smoked gouda or even a smoked mozzarella grilled cheese? Sourdough bread would also make a great base for a grilled Caprese sandwich, with hearty slices of tomato and fresh basil added to the cheese.

6. Pepperidge Farm Cinnamon Raisin Breakfast Bread

Pepperidge Farm Cinnamon Raisin Breakfast Bread

We know what you’re thinking: “cinnamon-raisin bread? For grilled cheese?” But hear us out. If you’ve ever had brie with a fruity topping like chutney or jam, you know how delicious the combination of tangy, earthy triple- or double-creme cheese and a sweet complement can be. So go ahead and fire up the stove.

If you’re not a fan of the intense, almost musky taste of some bries, ask your cheesemonger for a mild type. Which still offers all of the creamy goodness. With its relatively thin slices and subtle but unmistakable cinnamon profile, this raisin bread is one of the best breads for grilled cheese sandwich. It’s not just for breakfast anymore. But no one would judge you if you did eat this delicious, cheesy sammy for breakfast!

5. Mamas Bakery Challah Bread

best mamas bakery challah bread for grilled cheese

Rich, tender and eggy, challah bread is best known as a Jewish ceremonial loaf that is traditionally served on Sabbath. But that doesn’t mean you can only eat it once a week. The fact that it becomes golden-brown when butter and heat are applied means challah makes the best bread for grilled cheese.

Buck tradition by using thick slices, and ensure even cheese coverage by using a sharp or salty cheese that is grated, not sliced. Sharp cheddar or fontina offer a delicious contrast to the sweet, rich taste of the challah.

4. New Grains Gluten-Free Sandwich Bread

New Grains Gluten Free Bakery Bread

Whether they have been diagnosed with Celiac disease or simply because they feel that eating wheat-free gives them more energy and better digestion; anyone who has decided to cut out gluten from their diet knows the difficulty of finding a good gluten-free bread. All too often, these ersatz loaves are crumbly, dense or dry, go moldy too quickly, or simply don’t taste anything like “regular” wheat bread.

This loaf from New Grains is the exception to the rule. And as such, it can make the best gluten free bread for grilled cheese. Made with cold milled sweet white rice flour and cold milled sweet brown rice flour, this allergen-friendly bread can also be frozen without compromising its flavor or texture.

3. ThinSlim Foods Love-The-Taste Low Carb Bread

ThinSlim Foods Love-The-Taste Bread

Maybe you haven’t gone completely gluten free, but you are watching your carbohydrate intake. In that case, check out this low-carb version of the best bread for grilled cheeses. The “Love the Taste” brand from ThinSlim Foods has only 2g net carbs and 70 calories per slice.

It’s also low on the Glycemic Index (GI) scale. Pair it with a creamy, meltable Havarti, and you’ll be on your way to a superb sandwich that doesn’t taste like an imitation of the food you used to love.

2. Dorothy Lane Market New York Rye

Dorothy Lane Market New York Rye

A Reuben is one of the iconic deli sandwiches of all time. Although it can be somewhat time-consuming to make at home. However, you can get the great flavors of a Reuben by combining a New York-style rye bread, like this Dorothy Lane Market rye loaf, with a nutty Gruyere for a sophisticated take on the standard grilled cheese.

Slice it thin, slather on the butter to ensure a crisp exterior, and go to town. If you have any sauerkraut hiding in the back of your fridge, serve that on the side. And it will make you feel like you’re on the Lower East Side.

1. Arnold Whole Grain Classics 12 Grain Bread

Arnold Whole Grain 12 Grain Bread

Looking for a solid, all-purpose bread that combines the good taste of traditional sandwich bread with the health benefits of whole grain and fiber? Try making yourself a hot, toasty grilled cheese with Arnold Whole Grain Classics bread. It is our winner for the best bread for grilled cheese.

This will provide you with the best of both worlds: a sandwich bread that, as the saying goes, tastes great and is great for you. For the filling, choose a spicy pepper jack cheese. It will melt well and provide a zippy contrast to the slightly sweet, super nutty flavor of this bread. Which has an impressive 13g of whole grains per serving.


We hope we’ve inspired you to try some new breads, and maybe some unique cheese pairings, for your next grilled cheese sandwich. The most important thing to remember when it comes to building the ultimate lunch or snack is that the best bread for grilled cheese is the one that you love, paired with your favorite cheese. Bon appetit!

(Visited 9,136 times, 1 visits today)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.