7 Best Pepper Jack Cheese Options | Today Top Reviews Today Top Reviews

7 Best Pepper Jack Cheese Options

pepper jack cheese

Image from Pixabay

You’ve got to love a cheese with a first name. Sure “Asiago” sounds fancy, and “Cheddar” is synonymous with cash money. But when it comes to a cheese you can really get to know, it is preferable to be able to address it as “Jack.” Of course, Jack wears many hats. Sometimes, he’s hanging with Colby to create the marbled wonder we call Colby Jack. And sometimes, he’s flavored throughout with pepper flakes, and when that happens we call him pepper jack cheese.

Pepper jack cheese is a standout favorite among the plethora of cheeses one can choose. Its mild creamy taste and its semi-hard texture make the jack cheese the perfect vessel for bursts of peppery spice. A single slice of pepper jack cheese can do the improvement work to a sandwich that other cheeses can only achieve with the addition of horseradish sauce or some other, spicy, secondary ingredient.

In fact, if you’re like us, and you are perpetually harried about by the constant choices of the modern era, you probably choose pepper jack cheese because it narrows down your options for a sandwich. Pepper jack cheese kills two birds with one stone when it comes to sandwich construction, so it’s the logical choice.

Shullsburg Creamery - Ghost Pepper Cheese - 5 Pound Loaf

Image from Amazon

Pepper jack cheese is a standout favorite among the plethora of cheeses one can choose. Its mild creamy taste and its semi-hard texture make the jack cheese the perfect vessel for bursts of peppery spice. A single slice of pepper jack cheese can do the improvement work to a sandwich that other cheeses can only achieve with the addition of horseradish sauce or some other, spicy, secondary ingredient.

In fact, if you’re like us, and you are perpetually harried about by the constant choices of the modern era, you probably choose pepper jack cheese because it narrows down your options for a sandwich. Pepper jack cheese kills two birds with one stone when it comes to sandwich construction, so it’s the logical choice.

Pepper Jack Cheese FAQ

What Exactly Is Pepper Jack Cheese?

What Are the Other Varieties of Jack Cheese?

Who Invented Pepper Jack Cheese?

Where Can You Buy Pepper Jack Cheese?

Is It True That Pepper Jack Cheese Prevents Migraines?

How We Reviewed

pepper jack cheese

We take cheese seriously. We know many of our readers reach for Jack due to its anti-headache properties and want to provide them with the highest quality cheese research. The distinct features, production notes, pros, cons, price points, and brand reputations were all taken into consideration when narrowing down and presenting this list.

Overall Price Range of This Product (and Similar Products)

The rarity and quality of the Jack cheese will greatly affect its price. However, on average you can expect to pay 50 to 60 cents per ounce of cheese.

What We Reviewed

Kraft Natural Pepper Jack Cheese Sticks, 2 Ounce -- 28 per case.
  • Important - Refrigerated items are perishable and tend to have short shelf lives - some of these can be as little as two weeks from the date of receipt - if you are ordering a large quantity, or are otherwise concerned about expiration dates, consider a frozen product.

Features 

This is not our favorite pepper jack, but we did enjoy certain elements of this less expensive cheese option. Interestingly, Kraft is the only brand to enhance their peppers. They use acetic acid, instead of just regular old peppers. This leads us to believe acetic acid is the explanation behind the strange flavor.

The acid acts with an initial jolt of tart pepper like flavor, only to quickly dissipates into the regular old jack flavor. However, if you’re going to use this for an ingredient in a big dish, then it is probably fine.

Pros

  • Cheap 
  • Availability
  • A brand you know

Cons

  • Acetic acid enhanced 
  • Bland flavor 
  • Adds fat without spice
Pepper Jack Processed Cheese 6-4 oz Individually Wrapped Packages
  • Famous Wisconsin Cheese
  • no refrigeration required
  • Creamy and Delicious
  • Known Nationally
  • Shelf Stable

Features

Self-proclaimed attributes of this pepper jack cheese include the “Famous” nature of the product, shelf stability, and no refrigeration required. Since these are not the qualities we really look for outside of a summer sausage (ironically consumed in winter for the most part – explain that one), we give this cheese a middle rating. The taste is good and real peppers were used, so the flavor is maintained throughout. Overall, the product is great for your next taco or burger night.

Pros

  • Fine flavor
  • Shelf stable
  • No refrigeration required

Cons

  • Famous cheese
  • Price point
Tillamook Cheese Hot Habanero Jack 7 oz.
  • 7 ounces.
  • Hormone free.
  • Made In the USA.

Features 

Spicy, milky, and full flavored, this is up to par with every other Tillamook cheese we tried on our list. The brand never disappoints for a mid-range cheese with expensive flavor. If your budget is in a pinch, but you really love quality and quantity cheese, then this is the brand with which you can make a safe bet. Almost any variety of their cheese is above decent for the price. It’s not the best cheese you have ever had, but well worth your five bucks.

Pros

  • Quality for price
  • Easy to find
  • Great brand 
  • Great taste

Cons

  • Not the best cheese you have ever had
4oz Sonoma Jacks Gourmet Cheese Wedges Pepper Jack by Dairy Food (One Unit)
  • One unit per order
  • Contains: 6 - 0.67oz wedges per unit
  • Product of USA

Features

This certainly is the only gourmet pepper jack cheese that we included on our list and we love it. It has all the best elements of a jack cheese with plenty of pepper flavor to go around. Pepper Jack fills a lot of different roles in the lives of cheese eaters. Some want it for slices on their sandwiches, others want it as the perfect pre-spiced nacho cheese. And some want a slice that will help refresh their guests’ palates when they present a charcuterie board. This cheese is for those fancy scenarios.

Pros

  • Lots of peppers
  • Great flavor 
  • Gourmet cheese

Cons

  • Not so cheap
Naturally Good Kosher Cheese - Monterey Jack (0.516 pound)
  • Ships expedited in an insulated package to ensure freshness
  • Naturally Good Kosher cheeses promote a healthy way of life
  • 100% all natural and no artificial additives or preservatives are used
  • Maintain highly supervised production guidelines to ensure the best quality cheese with the most uncompromising flavor
  • Suitable for vegetarians and use no animal rennet

Features

If you’ve gone kosher, then this is the cheese of your dreams and the only kosher option on our list. It’s not as spicy as some of our daredevil options, or as cheap as the lowest on our list, but it has great flavor and a full palate taste.

The company wants to promote a healthy way of life; that’s why they made kosher cheese! In addition, they use 100% all natural ingredients and no artificial additives or preservatives. This is the way that everyone should make cheese. It’s even suitable for vegetarians!

Pros

  • Kosher and vegetarian 
  • Great taste 
  • 100 percent natural 
  • No additives or preservatives 
  • Promotes health

Cons

  • Price 
  • Shipping price
Habanero Ghost Pepper Cheese 4-Pack
  • This Ghost Pepper Monterey Jack has taken the traditional Pepper Jack and turned it on its head
  • Ghost Peppers, known as Bhut Jolokia chili peppers are 3 to 4 times hotter than habenero peppers!
  • Made with Wisconsin Jack Cheese and genuine ghost peppers
  • Includes 4 half pound pieces
  • Great on burgers, sandwiches, or with crackers

Features 

Is that regular cheese not spicy enough? Was that last jalapeno mild in flavor? This is the cheese for you. It will knock your socks off and make your ears red from the full flavor of these hot peppers. However, we do recommend that if you are not the spice-loving type, then you should steer clear of this cheese.

Pros

  • Made for spice lovers
  • Great hot flavor 
  • Full of taste in every bite

Cons

  • Not for the faint of heart
  • Can be considered too spicy
Shullsburg Creamery - Ghost Pepper Cheese - 5 Pound Loaf
  • American cheese with real ghost peppers
  • Extremely Hot!!
  • 3 to 4 times hotter than habanero's
  • Economical 5 pound loaf
  • Order more than one item from any of the Shullsburg Creamery product lines and save on shipping (see shipping rates and policies)

Features 

There is not much better than a hot cheese sandwich. This is certainly the cheese we would recommend for that imagined sandwich. It is full of flavor and peppers throughout. We loved it and so will you.

Pros

  • Awesome flavor 
  • Full of pepper 
  • Nice and hot

Cons

  • Not super cheap 
  • Not everyone’s favorite 
  • Not the hottest

The Verdict

The cheese we choose is naturally good kosher cheese, the Pepper Jack by Good Naturally. We love this company for the lack of preservatives and additives. It’s great for everyone even if you are a typical cheese and meat consumer. It’s just better to live healthily.

(Visited 39 times, 1 visits today)


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.